Album Review: Parker McCollum’s “Probably Wrong”


So here’s a conversation that a lot of indie country fans probably don’t want to have, but the sooner we have it the better off we’re all going to be: we have an image problem. And when I say that, the problem is that already we have certain expectations what an indie country act is supposed to look or sound like, and as much as we’re supposed to be more willing to embrace sounds that buck trends, we have trends of our own. Trust a guy who has covered plenty of it in the past few years, this genre is saturated with guys with gruff raspy baritones and grizzled beards leaning towards southern rock, or girls with alternative hair cuts and husky voices and tones touching on rockabilly or smooth jazz. And don’t get me wrong, I like that image and sound and I like many of the artists that use it, but if we start using it as a barricade against acts coming into the indie country space that could definitely have a place here, that’s a problem.

So take Parker McCollum, a guy who’s two years younger than me and looks like he could be fronting any bro-country act… and yet dig a little deeper and you end up finding a lot more. For one, he runs his own independent label where he’s been releasing projects for the past five years, and going into his first album The Limestone Kid, there’s nary a drum machine or drop of Autotune in sight: just straightforward, hardscrabble Texas country with fiddle, pedal steel, rough-edged guitars, and damn good melodies to boot – you can definitely hear the Ryan Bingham and Townes Van Zant influences creeping in. Now that 2015 debut is far from flawless – the songwriting can feel a little iffy at points, and it was clear that McCollum was still growing into his voice, but there was promise there. And when I heard his sophomore project was coming out this year, bundling two EPs plus a few new songs, I was pretty excited – yes, the buzz was suggesting he maybe was adding a little more of a pop flourish with more piano, but if the sound was good and the Texas country edge remained prominent, I had high hopes for this. So, what did I find on Probably Wrong?


Overall Rating: 7/10


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *